Photo by: flickr user saxonmoseley

Quiet and Brave

The Great War, ninety years on.

By Alex Massie,  November 10, 2008


And then there were three. Henry Allingham, 112, Harry Patch, 110 and William Stone, a mere stripling at 108, are the only ones left. They are the last three men living in Britain who served in the First World War. This morning they will assemble, for perhaps the final time, at the Cenotaph in Whitehall, where, at 11am, 90 years to the minute since the guns fell silent, the final veterans of the Great War will lead the nation in a two minute silence that honors all the country's war dead in all its many wars.

The continuing conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan have concentrated minds in this remembrance season, but it is still the First World War that is the primary focus of attention and, yes, grief, even 90 years on. Indeed, the more the Great War recedes into the distance, the greater the interest in it. As the number of survivors has dwindled to a handful over the past decade, so the war has become more, not less important. Soon even these doughty survivors will leave us and the final flesh-and-blood links to the carnage will be gone.  It will, once more, be as Robert Graves put it, "Goodbye to All That".

Perhaps interest in the Great War will slacken then, but I doubt it. The arguments still rage. Each year new histories appear, new television series are commissioned and new novels with the war as its backdrop are published. Sebastian Faulks' Birdsong was perhaps the most popular British literary novel of the past 15 years, selling more than three million copies, while Pat Barker won the Booker Prize for The Ghost Road, the final volume of her First World War trilogy. The war continues to compel a dreadful fascination.

So perhaps it's not surprising that anyone visiting Britain at this time of year cannot help but be struck by the little red paper poppies sported by much of the populace. More than forty million of the paper flowers, modeled on the blood-red poppies that grew in Flanders' fields, were distributed this year, the proceeds going to the Royal British Legion, a charity which cares for ex-servicemen.

The Labour government recently dropped proposals for a new national holiday that would celebrate "Britishness." And rightly so. The proposal was met with scorn and ridicule, largely because no-one felt there was any need for a public display of flag-waving. In any case, Remembrance Sunday and the anniversary of the Armistice are enough. Though a somber affair, these days remind us all of the common bonds that tie the country together: bonds of blood and time and sacrifice in periods of monumental collective effort.

Typically, it's the defeats and disasters that echo more strongly down the years. Dunkirk looms larger in the popular imagination than el-Alamein; the Somme and Passchendaele define the First World War more thoroughly than the great victories of 1918.

Rating:
(9 ratings)
Print | Email |Share: Share on Facebook Post to MySpace Share with Mixx Digg This Share with Reddit Share with Stumble Upon

Comments

Nathan P Origer November 11, 2008 1:14 pm
Nice piece, Mr. Massie. I rather enjoy getting a European perspective on this somber day.
Anonymous November 11, 2008 10:19 pm
WWI When a whole lot of stupid euros decided to get themselves killed and then managed to sucker us into it. If Japan had not helped, we would not have been suckered in WW2. World War One has the unique distinction of being the only truly senseless war in history, one that really made no sense to either side but no one could resist joining the fun, especially after the Brits decided to make the world safe for waffles. So off the damned fools went, cheering for the opportunity to die in the mud, for nothing. The lemmings had nothing on them. Let us not be so foolish to honor their memory. Let us heap upon them the derision and ridicule that they deserve and be thankful that soon the last of them will be dead.
Anonymous November 12, 2008 6:59 am
My grandfather, who was decorated in WWI and lost two brothers in it, always told me not to wear a poppy as it engendered the acceptability of militarism in the wider population. I thought that he was wrong until recently. Witness the military bands playing uplifting tunes after the silence, people marching. He used to say, "Always remember, old soldier - old shite". Not having served it's not a view I am allowed to share. He thought that if you had seen the horror of war, then you couldn't talk about it. Seeing lots of people speak about their experiences of war on the telly, and, almost ubiquitously, their apparent stoicism, I am starting to wonder if the whole point of rememberence has been hijacked by recruiting officers. I always remember the dead and wounded, including my grandfather, and always honour them by opposing the unnecessary war that we are now engaged in.
Walter Koehler November 12, 2008 12:24 pm
Paul Fussell, in his indispensible book The Great War and Modern Memory, savagely attacks John McRae's poem "In Flanders Fields" for similar reasons.
Walter Koehler November 12, 2008 12:22 pm
We can scorn the fools who brought on World War I without deriding those who went off to die in the trenches for no good reason. I believe that World War I is one of the great turning points in all of human history, one that we still haven't come to grips with. Before 1914, all reasonable people believed that progress was being made and that, overall, things were always getting better. Then the most developed countries in the world destroyed each other for reasons that nobody can explain to this day. World War II and the Holocaust raised the stakes horribly, but it was the Great War that ripped us from nature and dumped us into existential hell.

Comment

Your name: Anonymous   [Show your name]



(Maximum 2000 characters with spaces)
Culture11 Poll

Where do you get the majority of your news?

Feedback Form